Tag Archives: health care leadership

The Quandary of Cracks

Cracks present a quandary.

When you are trying to coordinate a health ecosystem comprised of multiple, dedicated but widely different parts with potentially disparate agendas it’s usually not the individual components that are the challenge. It is dealing with the cracks between them.

In recognizing and responding to the cracks, there are several options. You can rail against the lack of a single, synchronized system. You can ignore the cracks and just deal with the separate parts. You can work around the cracks by building a myriad of small bridges with each different entity. These tend to be fragile and dependent on the individuals involved. They also tend to collapse if circumstances change (including transitions of the bridge-building brokers). Alternatively, you can press into the strength of the range of expertise and experience and develop the language and formalized relationships that can unite the different entities into a single system for a singular purpose.

Consider this example. A nurse practitioner who regularly works in a city hospital is attached for 12 months to augment the City Health Department’s street medicine program that is focused on overdose prevention. Her paycheck, paid time off, evaluation process and all administrative aspects of her job remain with the hospital. But the Street Medicine director determines which of the health department’s street teams she is assigned to, when they go into the community and to which geographic area. Negotiations regarding the funding of her position would be conducted between the two entities.

For all intents and purposes, that nurse practitioner is now a part of the health department’s operations, but at the same time still belongs to the hospital that “loaned” her. Her hospital provides continued “administrative control” (ADCON) for her. The health department’s street medicine director provides “operational control” (OPCON) of the practitioner’s time and effort. The City Health Commissioner, who in this hypothetical case is responsible for decreasing deaths from overdose in the city provides strategic oversight; determining how much of her budget is devoted to the street teams as a part of this effort based on the mayor’s guidance and strategic priorities. The nurse practitioner on loan from one of the city’s hospitals is now a vital component of her overarching strategy and provides a direct professional link between the street team and the hospital allowing for improved communication, enhanced referrals and greater understanding of the components by all the elements of the ecosystem.

The military has a long history of working with different agencies and services in settings where one service or organization leader has operational leadership authority. In Baltimore City during the COVID-19 pandemic, we demonstrated that this model could work outside the military. The Baltimore Convention Center Field Hospital (BCCFH) was staffed and run by a combination of nursing staff from University of Maryland Medical System (UMMS), providers from Johns Hopkins Medicine (JHM) and a range of contracted staff (e.g. security, logistics, information technology, convention center staff).

Executive leaders for the BCCFH came from both health systems and worked together as a team. The medical systems and contractors retained ADCON for their assigned staff. The BCCFH Director was a Johns Hopkins faculty member who provided OPCON over the contractors, Hopkins and UMMS staff assigned. The BCCFH Director was accountable to the Maryland Secretary of Health (whose department funded the operation) as well as a board of senior leaders from the state health department, Hopkins and University of Maryland health care systems. The Secretary and this board exercised strategic oversight for all BCCFH operations (e.g. inpatient care, ambulatory infusion, testing, vaccination etc.)

Three blocks to the north during the pandemic, the TRI (“Triage, Respite, Isolation”) Support Center located at the Lord Baltimore Hotel was a Baltimore City operation for individuals with COVID-19 who had no safe place to isolate. Thus, OPCON fell to the City of Baltimore’s designated leaders: the site clinical directors who were Hopkins employees attached to the city for this COVID-19 effort. They had OPCON over individuals working in the hotel including all nursing personnel from UMMS and staff from other city agencies. These leaders set policy and procedures in collaboration and consultation with leaders from the other engaged organizations: UMMS, the Mayor’s Office of Homeless Services (MOHS), the Mayor’s Emergency Operations Center (EOC), and Hotel Management.

The operational leaders were accountable to an executive leadership board that included a representative from UMMS, one from the Mayor’s office and the City Health Commissioner, who served as the board chair. The three executives provided strategic oversight and guidance for the operational leadership. The individual organizations responsible for the staff working in the hotel (e.g. UMMS, MOHS, Mayor’s Office, Hotel Management, and contracted security) retained ADCON of their personnel.

While the specific terms “OPCON” and “ADCON” were not used during the pandemic to delineate these operational relationships, this model of centralized authority, shared resources and clearly defined accountability were key to the city’s remarkable success in the pandemic.

Although state and city lines of authority differed between these two efforts, in this case the City Health Commissioner and the health department coordinated the citywide pandemic response. There were obvious cracks. But to the average residents of our city, they were largely invisible. As an example, the Baltimore Mayor or Health Commissioner was much more likely to get compliments on Twitter or Facebook for the convention center vaccine or testing operation than the governor. Although the lines of authority were not always clear (or consistently followed) the city effort functioned as a crisis-driven system of health, ostensibly under the health commissioner as the strategic leader responsible for developing collaborative coordination and the city’s strategic communication plan.

Between 2018 and 2022, Baltimore became the per capita overdose capital of the Nation, boasting a fatal overdose rate that was nearly double that of other large US cities. However, for decades the city has had numerous dedicated civic and community-based organizations, daily addressing the challenges of this syndemic. For example, ten years ago, Baltimore was the first municipality in Maryland to allow naloxone to be obtained by individuals without a provider’s prescription. More recently, in part supported by the city’s opioid restitution funds, targeted efforts have been taken and the rate of death from overdose continues to decrease and is down 23% compared to last year. But insufficient clarity around operational relationships and the absence of a central coordinating authority remain, resulting in cracks in the efforts to provide a continuum of care for individuals at risk of overdose from OUD. In our city, aggressive efforts are underway to remedy this.

The COVID-19 pandemic was defeated by a city wide coordinated, cooperative and collaborative effort. Nationally, the opioid syndemic has raged for more than a quarter century at the cost of more than a million lives with more than six million adults and adolescents still suffering from OUD including thousands in Baltimore. While laudable efforts are underway, this population still lacks a unified system of health for their care.

The opioid restitution fund is an unparalleled opportunity for our city and for municipalities across the country. An infusion of new money is good. An infusion of new thinking might be even better. As with the pandemic, resources and reorganized health care operations could be coordinated to “close the cracks” in our city’s overdose syndemic response as well.

We have figured this out before.

 

Chuck Callahan Henry V 4.3 – Lead from the Front https://henryv43.com/

“The views expressed by Dr. Callahan are his own, and do not reflect the official policy or position of the BCORE project leadership, (“Baltimore’s Comprehensive Overdose Response to End the Epidemic”), the University of Maryland School of Medicine, the University of Maryland, Baltimore, or any agency or department of the Baltimore City, Maryland or U.S. Governments.”

 

 

 

1 Comment

Filed under health care leadership, Organizational Leadership, Uncategorized

On being a loose cannon.

It is a distant memory at this point. I remember a single feedback session during my years as a pediatric resident. It was probably early in my junior resident year when senior residents and staff took call from home. My mentor was a respected senior oncologist. When we met, I could tell that he was struggling to summarize the staff’s evaluation of me.

He was finally able to put it into a single sentence:
“Chuck, you’re kind of perceived as being a loose cannon.”

It was a fair assessment.

I was the one who was most apt to forget to call the staff on call before starting a procedure. I acted at times as though I thought that policies and protocols just slowed us down. And I could stretch the rules slightly to help patients move through the systems more efficiently.

In retrospect, the eighties were a time when hospitals were much more dangerous. This kind of thinking didn’t help. Continue reading →

3 Comments

Filed under General Leadership, health care leadership, Personal Leadership

Community Health Work: “What do I need to know?”

A few months ago, an executive coach I’ve known since the early months of the pandemic asked me a question about the community health work I have been doing for the past several years.

“Tell me five things about working in the community that you think I should know.”

I have thought about the question and the answers I spontaneously gave him since, confident that one thing is certain: I don’t really know completely. And I know that I won’t ever completely know. So in that spirit of true humility, when asked I focused on what I was learning, and I gave it a try.

It is worth noting that I spent the first thirty of the forty years of my professional career in the U.S. Military, where everyone had a job, a house, education and access to free health care. It is clear to me now that military members are under greater stress from health related social needs than I realized while I was in uniform. Regardless, in the transition a decade ago from this successful, single-payer, government health system, the biggest wakeup call I experienced was coming face to face with the lack of the same social supports for the patients I now cared for.

For the past decade, I worked in population health as the payer systems evolved to include models of “value-based care.” Over time, it became clear that the greatest value we could provide would be to work with community partners to assure economic growth and stability, housing, transportation and food access as well as health education and seamless health care access for our patients. The individuals of the urban community where my wife and I have lived, worked and worshiped have vastly different life experiences than we do. We continue to learn from them.

Since stepping away from a hospital population health role eighteen months ago, my role has largely been in community health. Thus, my coach’s request. This is what I told him. Continue reading →

2 Comments

Filed under health care leadership, Uncategorized

The case for a cowboy.

For the last several years, I have been using Dr. Atul Gawande’s graduation speech to the Harvard Medical School Class of 2011 (“Cowboys and Pit Crews”) in teaching about the evolution of health care delivery I have witnessed over my years in practice.

When my medical career began (during Reagan’s first presidential term), hierarchical “parallel mono-disciplinary” care was the typical patient’s experience, where a patient was passed between specialists and hospitals until someone (hopefully) took the time to sit down and listen to their journey, piece together the story, mine the available paper records and validate the patient’s concerns with a reasonable differential diagnostic and therapeutic plan. This pattern of care delivery continues in many settings today.

In the closing decades of the last century we moved forward considerably with multidisciplinary (multiple specialties looking at the same patient at the same time, often in the same clinical space) and interdisciplinary teams (multiple specialties looking at the same patient at the same time, including the voice of patient and family, and agreeing on a single patient and family-centered set of treatment goals).

More recently, we have increasingly recognized that health is more than the absence of disease. The true drivers of health are determined by the 8,759 hours a year our patients spend at home in their community rather than the roughly one hour a year the average American spends in a provider’s office. In the future, the individual and population’s health will be addressed by a new model of integrated, community-care teams that include health care professionals but also community navigators and service providers as equal partners who are able to address issues like housing, food security, employment and economics. (But that’s the subject for another post.)

Time has proven that Dr. Gawande was right. The future of health care depends on our ability to function like pit crew teams with broad, horizontal, flexible, situational leadership structures.

But for the past several weeks, I wish we had a cowboy. Continue reading →

7 Comments

Filed under health care leadership, Organizational Leadership

Imperatives of Leadership: A Pandemic Response

“We few, we happy few, we band of brothers…”

The name of this website was inspired by an article on leadership based on two books by Sandhurst military historian John Keegan. The Face of Battle was his 1976 analysis of major battles in history including Agincourt (October 27, 1415). His 1987 book The Mask of Command highlighted styles of military leadership through history and concluded with five of what Keegan considered to be the “Imperatives of Leadership:” kinship, prescription, sanction, action, and example. The 1998 article examined Shakespeare’s speech by Henry at Agincourt (Henry V, Act 4, Scene 3) as an example of Keegan’s leadership imperatives.

In the early spring of 2020 as the COVID pandemic gained momentum, US Army Colonel (Retired) Dr. Jim Ficke and I were asked at the behest of the Governor to stand up a field hospital in the Baltimore Convention Center with a number of leaders from Johns Hopkins Medicine, the University of Maryland Medical Center and the Maryland Department of Health.

Fifteen months later the team concluded inpatient operations after providing care for 1,495 inpatients with COVID. Along the way (and often with short notice) we added missions including a mass COVID testing capability and later numerous community sites that have performed more than 110,000 tests to date. Monoclonal antibody infusions were added in the autumn of 2020 and more than 2,300 have been provided since. And finally, when vaccines became available,  a large-scale vaccination center was opened that has provided more than 122,000 vaccinations since February 2021. The Baltimore Convention Center Field Hospital (BCCFH) is almost certainly the longest continually operating convention center COVID hospital in the nation, and probably the only one where the same team also provided ambulatory infusion treatment, large scale COVID testing and vaccination.

In retrospect, Keegan’s imperatives of leadership were the standard as we established and operated the hospital. In many ways, they were key elements of its success. Continue reading →

3 Comments

Filed under Organizational Leadership, Personal Leadership

“Is this your field hospital?”

“Is this your field hospital?”

This question is the reason I wear a tie to all our COVID testing events. I want people to know where they can direct complaints or concerns. I walked over to the gentleman who asked the question and steeled myself for “constructive feedback.”

It has been six months of almost exclusively COVID. Since mid-winter and my taking the role of Hospital Incident Command’s “Community Liaison,” the population health job has taken on a very specific focus as COVID has become the latest of the threats to the health for our community.

We started in early March by planning for hospital COVID testing and working with community health on food distribution after the schools closed and many of the children in the community lost access to several of their daily meals. By mid-month, a group of us from the two largest medical systems in our city met with the State Health Department and were directed to construct and operate a FEMA field hospital in the convention center. Continue reading →

6 Comments

Filed under Organizational Leadership, Uncategorized

A source of medical leader ineffectiveness?

Some of the same skills that make physicians, nurses, medical administrators and allied health professionals excel in our clinical roles can potentially hinder our effectiveness as leaders. If the process of recognizing these risks were automatic we wouldn’t need to think about it. And there would be an even greater number of effective healthcare leaders.

Unfortunately, every group I speak with can quickly relate stories of a bad leader or two. While bad leadership may be common, I contend that intentionally bad leadership is rare. People don’t get up in the morning, and while shaving or brushing their hair, look in the mirror and say, “Today I will be a bad leader.  I will mismanage and mess with someone’s career…” That should be sobering for us, however well-intentioned we may be. In the spirit of continual reflection and renewal, it’s worth examining three strengths we develop in the study and practice of healthcare that can sometimes be leadership liabilities.

Talented tacticians.
Healthcare is inherently tactical.  We learn the craft of medicine one patient at a time: one exam room, one hospital bed, one operating room.  It is a pattern reinforced through decades of training during the crucial years of adult development. After training, daily practice is a series of independent encounters in the ambulatory or inpatient arenas.  The rules of patient privacy necessitate our forgetting the last patient as we move onto the next.  Sometimes we may not think about them again until the lab or consult comes back, or we see them in follow-up.  There is little time or expectation for the awareness necessary to string together patterns of patient problems or behaviors, or for us to think about the larger, strategic implications of our medical practice.  The way of thinking may spill over into our personal lives where our best intentions to be the people/partners/parents we know we should be become lost in the tyranny of day-to-day “tactical” execution (drive the kids, take out the trash, finish the lawn etc). Continue reading →

1 Comment

Filed under Organizational Leadership, Personal Leadership